Status Updates
Photos
Powered by Squarespace
Microblog
Search and Subscribe
Reading List

What I'm reading - starred items from Instapaper.

« The Tea Partys War on Education | Main | Iowa GOP Leader predicts ouster of more judges »
Thursday
Dec022010

Tell me Mr. Ryan, what exactly is "limited" government?

Rep. Paul Ryan, Columnist David Brooks Debate 'Limited' Government:

During the rejoinders, Ryan responded by saying that our nation has gone from assuming our rights were derived from God to assuming our rights come from government. "And so, I do believe that the idea of the role of government has changed," he said.

I would contend that "limited government" is an oxymoron. The government is supposed to derive it's powers from the consent of the governed, therefore intrinsically limiting it to what the citizens want it to be.

Putting some sort of arbitrary limit on the powers of government is, in my opinion, antithetical to the nature of our democratic system. The government should not be allowed to create it's own power, but that is not the same as summarily limiting what the government has the power to do. Those decisions are made by the citizens through our representatives in Congress.

Now, whether or not Congress (i.e. Politicians) is bastardizing their role in the governmental process is an entirely different discussion. But I think that for the purposes of this venue, Brooks is right and Ryan is a little too caught up in the semantic argument about the role of government as opposed to it's overall function.

Reader Comments (1)

"I quite agree with you.All right. I agree with you.I really disagree with you. Women should enjoy the same rights as men. Why can't a woman have her own career?Personally, I do not agree with this viewIf the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth;First, ask questions. Asking question doesn't mean you disagree with the statement. It simply means you're curious. You want to learn more.
"
November 3, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterCanada Goose Jackets

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.